As I said, Devin, I can work with smaller handles. I typically have my index finger pointing down the blade when I’m sawing, and if it’s a too-small-handle, my pinky is outside the handle somehow too. But a two-finger grip like that isn’t comfortable for an extended session, and if it’s my saw, I’ll either replace the handle or file off the pinky-end of it so it’s more accommodating to big hands. 

May you have the day you deserve!