Wow, something incredible happened.
Today at Urban Ore, they pulled me aside to tell me that they owe me $9.
Turns out that pack of rifflers was to be sold for $9 total, not to be opened and individually sold for $9 a piece.
So when I opened the bundle and cherry-picked two that I wanted and handed them back 4, then paid $18, that was incorrect.
Today they gave me an option, and I took the remaining rifflers AND $9 off my next purchase.
So now I have these to clean up as well