Looking into Oneida Supercell

86
5
I have been struggling with way too much dust lately. My 25 year old PS dust collector was never any good, but I didn't do anything about it. The more I research, the more confused I get. I was thinking it might be time to bite the bullet and get a real dust collector. I should have dealt with this years ago. Now that I have the money to upgrade, I don't feel like I have enough years left to get my monies worth.šŸ¤Ŗ I read several reviews and even the ones that were rated 5 stars all said it was very loud and produced a lot of heat.
I just upgraded my exhaust fan that came with my laser. Everything was getting covered with soot and it was hard to see through the enclosure because of the smoke. I switched to an inline fan that works so well, I don't even see any smoke when using the laser. I'm sure it will not only keep the enclosure clean, but also keep all the soot out of the laser itself.
I'm sure there are several ways I could improve what I have now, but I just want to buy something that works and needs no improvements. If you have one of Oneida's units I'd love to hear your opinion. Thanks in advance.

.................. John D....................

Absolutely love mine. Best purchase Iā€™ve ever made for the shop. Itā€™s maybe a little loud, but I wear ear protection all the time so I hardly even know itā€™s on over the noise of the other tools. I donā€™t know that itā€™s much louder than a conventional DC, but the pitch is a bit higher so maybe thatā€™s more annoying? Again, doesnā€™t bother me even when I do a fast cut or something and donā€™t put in ear plugs, and donā€™t even notice it with ear plugs.Ā 

Itā€™s got enough suction that you can move it to a more remote portion of the shop if youā€™d like as well. Adding another 20 feet of ducting (if youā€™ve got the room) doesnā€™t effect its function at all.Ā 

As for heat, maybe a little bit but I havenā€™t really noticed it. If itā€™s an issue, you could always build it into a closet and do some venting for it during the summer. My shop is 425 sqft, with an open rafter ceiling, so I suppose if thereā€™s heat maybe Iā€™m storing some of it up there.Ā 

FWIW, Iā€™d make the purchase again in a secondā€¦and Iā€™d buy the turbo model because ā€˜buy once cry onceā€™ is real!

Ryan/// ~sigh~ I blew up another bowl. Moke told me "I made the inside bigger than the outside".

John I too had been looking. In December I took a few classes at the local WoodCraft store. In their shop area, they have a used every day. almost all hours they are open, it's in use. All of the big tools, and duplicates of a few bandsaws, and a lot of routers. Their only dust collection is a 2 HP Jet unit with cyclone attached.

We ran a lot of machines, often many at once, and that thing never slowed down. I asked Tony about it, and he told me at the time he'd suggest a different one. So I ended up with 20% off (storewide Christmas discount on all Rikon tools) and I got this Rikon, more power, more CFM's and he has several customers using one, and all good reports coming back. I love mine so far, but to be fair it's new, so it should get a longer test, before a full scale review. My Rikon for $1599.00 A LOT sweeter price than the Oneida, so if it offers as good a run, I'm really happy. I just couldn't reconcile that price tag.
Thanks Ryan, it sure is a hard pill to swallow, but I need to do something.

Thank you George, I'll look into that one. BTW, how did the misses like the etched wine glass?

.................. John D....................

The issue you get into with the more traditional DCs is that they donā€™t usually work well with smaller tools because they canā€™t create enough pressure. Anything under about a 4ā€ dust ports and traditional low pressure DCs start to sufferā€¦and youā€™ve got to pay attention to your ducting too. So, if youā€™re using ROS, hand routers with dust ports, whatever, youā€™ll need a high pressure system as well (read: shop vac). Thatā€™s the biggest reason I went with the supercell: it works with everything from my planer and jointer and table saw, all the way down to my ROS and Shaper Origin, all in one unit. That, coupled with the GRIT blast gates, means the entire shop is tied together through one systemā€¦and you can use whatever you want for ducting. Cheap drain pipe works great!

Of course to each their own (and price is a REAL thing) but, with the high pressure system, I have no problem with chips and very limited ā€˜floatersā€™ for the air cleaners to clean upā€¦no matter which tool Iā€™m using. If the table saw is the heart of the shop, the DC is the lungsā€¦plan accordingly for your shop needs in the long term no matter which way you go.Ā 

Ryan/// ~sigh~ I blew up another bowl. Moke told me "I made the inside bigger than the outside".

Because of the cost, I waited several years before I finally pulled the trigger on the Supercell last year.Ā  It is a loud mother and it does generate some heat. but the suction is incredible.Ā  I generally wear hearing protection for most of the machines where I use the SC anyway so the noise is not that big deal for me.Ā  This time of year the heat is not a problem but in the summer, it will definitely raise the shop temperature for long runs so I sometimes crank the AC down if I know I am going to be running it a lot. Ā  Fortunately, my minisplit is usually able to keep up, even last summer when we had many days over 100Ā°F. Ā  If I had a way, I would definitely put it outside my shop to mitigate both the noise and the heat.Ā  Ā Ā  I was able to get rid of my shop vac/cyclone so it does not really take any more room in my shop than my old shop vac did.Ā  It is pretty amazing how much suction it maintains with small hoses.Ā  With most DCs you really sacrifice suction when you choke down the hose but if anything, you have to be careful that the suction while using a shop vac hose doesn't suck up nearby things you may not want drawn into the hose.Ā  Ā Ā 

Just be aware that in general, you have to use vacuum rated hoses because the high suction will collapse the standard flexible DC hose lengthwise and if on a mobile cart (I built my own), it can pull itself across the shop.Ā  Standard shop vac hoses work fine and they include 20' of heavy duty 4" hose.Ā  The included hose is probably more accurately called flexible duct. Ā  It is pretty stiff so may not be the best for moving from machine to machine like you may do with normal 4" or 2" flexible DC hoses. Ā  It does not compress in length at all and it requires significant space to store when not in use so the best use of it is probablyĀ  for static runs where it is not in the way or suspended from the ceiling as you would for standard ducts.Ā Ā  I still haven't made permanent runs across my ceiling because I will probably have to redo my shop lighting first -- analysis paralysis and procrastination.Ā 

Even with the price tag, noise and heat I would buy it again.Ā  I didn't haveĀ  good place to hang the cheapest unit on the wall and I didn't want to pay the premium one of the mobile versions so I built a cart and that works very well.Ā  You can see it in my blog on the Supercell. Ā Ā 


--Nathan, TX. Hire the lazy man. He may not do as much work but that's because he will find a better way.