Maloof Low Back Chair

163
44

well here is the good, bad, and the ugly. and there is bad. i started this project about a year ago but kinda lost interest when things went sour. ill show some pic's of that. i had no plans to keep this chair, just made it because i love Maloof style furniture. you see i used a lot of sap wood which normally a chair like this i wouldn't but i just wanted to use up what walnut i had on hand so i didn't care. i used plans from Charles Brock. comes with full size templates, an instruction book and step by step CD. one thing if you ever do this chair make the seat at least 2" wider or it will be very snug. this was told to me by someone on another site. that is what caused one of the screw ups. Charles is very good about answering questions. i emailed him a couple times and he got right back. the plugs are maple. finish is 3 coats general finishes satin gel finish oil based. i took pic's in the begging of assembly and posted on my patio forum but they were lost.
NOW FOR SOME BAD !


even though i used his templates the arms were about 1/2" too short, so rather than start over i just filled in. wasn't keeping it anyway.


well i said you need to make the chair a couple inches wider, which i intended to do, but forgot and just used the template that came with it. so i had a bisquit show on both sides. well another fill in. sucks !!!!
so this is why it sat on mt bench all year until my friend was over and saw it. he loved it as is. so i said, you want it. he goes, hell ya. so i finished the sanding and got 3 coats on last week. waiting for him to get it outta here ! 
now i could have taken pic's that didn't show the mistakes but i want anyone that attempts this to avoid these problems.

working with my hands is a joy,it gives me a sense of fulfillment,somthing so many seek and so few find.-SAM MALOOF.

44 Comments

Faults???  or not it looks pretty nice.   The general shape, blending joints all good.   It is a fine chair!

Ron

thanks ron.

working with my hands is a joy,it gives me a sense of fulfillment,somthing so many seek and so few find.-SAM MALOOF.

Wow, that's purty! If you hadn't pointed out the faults, nobody would likely notice. Make another messed-up one and give it to me! 😊

The Other Steven

thanks DL but i wanted to be honest about it. 

working with my hands is a joy,it gives me a sense of fulfillment,somthing so many seek and so few find.-SAM MALOOF.

Fine work regardless!

Love the contouring and of course the butt-groove!
I think it looks very nice!  That walnut is sweet!

MosquitoMade.com

You are absolutely crazy man!!! That is a great chair...the fill in pieces are just fancy segmenting....if you never said anything no one would notice, but we as Woodworkers just do that....point out our mistakes...if you give that to that guy you are nuts...Keep that...it is beautiful!!!
Great work....be proud, not ashamed!

Mike

Looks great to me. The "fixes" could easily be viewed as design features. Your friend is fortunate you lost interest!
Yeah, mistakes can be kind of disappointing. But in the  woodworking world, we can also be our own worst enemy. I think the chair looks fantastic. Love the lumber. I admire your honesty for posting those mistakes. I'm forever fixing the goofs on my projects. No shame in that...
That is a beautiful creation Pottz, no doubt about it. The wood beauty is second only to the outstanding sculpting. Fret not about what you think of as mistakes, they add to the beauty of the chair, especially the lengthening of the arms, and we all make errors, it's part of the process.
Pottz,

That is a nice chair.  It took me to get to 60 years old not to show my mistakes.

I will say this if you are unhappy with it don't sign it.  Auto body friend told me a story how someone wanted the car to be rattle can painted.  He said someday you will tell someone I did that job.  He did not want the bad review.

Still I like the chair.


Petey

There’s nothing wrong with that imperfect chair—it looks great. 😉
Nice chair. Sam would be proud of you, Pottzy!!

Cheers, Jim ........................ Variety is the spice of life...............Learn something new every day

thanks guys for the very nice comments. after the Maloof rocker and the stool i think i got to over confident and didn't take my time double checking everything. but it will go to a new home. as i said i never really made it to keep anyway. hard to say what sam would have told me. one of his boys (larry white) told me at a seminar after he passed some of the gaffs sam would make, so maybe i shouldn't feel to ashamed ?

working with my hands is a joy,it gives me a sense of fulfillment,somthing so many seek and so few find.-SAM MALOOF.


That musta hurt, telling people something constructive (pun intended) out of left field other than "I made this".

A chair will never be wide enough for some people... Charles Brock may never have heard of your favourite restaurant(S)... hell, a flat stool/bench is never wide enough for my fat rrrs.

That 1/2" short cant be blamed on the cold weather/water,

and is a perfect example of how you can recover from some of the greatest oopsies.  Maybe, could have been a greatest disaster, but you'll never know now, a maple insert, to match the dowels,

could have morphed it from something you hated into a Pottzy treasured creation.

As for that tenon, blame it on Yankee policy makers... would never happen with a metric system... all your imperial fractions nearly always make things a fraction too short or too long. 

If your first cut is too short... Take the second cut from the longer end... LBD

Yeah, curious about the width being fit for lean people and not us broad in the beam types.
Was the arm too short in the plan/template or just cutting from the short end of the board? If so, LBDs advice would have worked!
Hopefully the plan guy adopted your corrections!
damn you ducks, even though you just pissed me off, i gotta say you always enlighten me in some stupid way !!!! i knew you would love i took my f ups and turned them into something someone could learn from.
your idea of using maple for the arm stretch would have been great ! instead of a screw up it's a design development ? it's actually something same used on the bottom of the rocker legs !
as for the tenon, no that was my screw up forgetting to widen the seat. now for your fat duck ass id have needed about 6" !!!!!
anyway thanks for the constructive and destructive comments as usual ! 🙄😎

working with my hands is a joy,it gives me a sense of fulfillment,somthing so many seek and so few find.-SAM MALOOF.

Looks great, Pottz. Those "mistakes", or as i like to call them... "design opportunities", can really be a downer sometimes! But you recovered well. Maybe use of a contrasting wood there would have made it seem like a design element rather than a patch although that may have messed up the nice flow you have... all in all, well done on a challenging project!

Angellos

coming from you i am honored !!!!!!!!! thank you my friend 😎

working with my hands is a joy,it gives me a sense of fulfillment,somthing so many seek and so few find.-SAM MALOOF.

 now for your fat duck ass id have needed about 6" !!!!! 

And don't forget... BIGGER lips.

If your first cut is too short... Take the second cut from the longer end... LBD